To my readers......

SITE UPDATE NOTICE

Thanks for visiting mitchmen, home of Mitchell's Gay Art

The Caps and Collars/ Flat Cap Gang story at Google Groups has been on a break since January,
I am working on it and hope to resume shortly. (see Group News for link)

Link to the Royale Studio Archive in the right sidebar


Message updated 6th Sept 2024

Sunday, 12 January 2020

The Russians are coming - 1

Memorable restraint images from Russian Captured Boys

Andrei in Chains
As an example of restraint this takes some beating. No wonder Andrei looks frustrated. Not only is he restricted by these heavyweight chains, he's weighed down by them, a constant reminder of captivity. 
That's a fate worthy of a superhero.

After this he's forced to do exercises wearing them
(image referenced is in Snakes and Chains post) 


Maxim's bamboo leverage restraint
 I don't know the exact term for this form of restraint, where arms and legs are tied in a flexed position with a stave of some sort trapped in crook of the joint, but it's totally immobilising.
Mischievous-looking Maxim here seems to be just beginning to appreciate that it's not a joke. 

In time he may also discover that the bamboo poles can put uncomfortable pressure on his joints if the ties are tight. They act as levers, particularly thick ones like this. Historically in South East Asia shibari bondage was used not only to restrain prisoners of war but to incapacitate them. The use of bamboo for the poles here together with a futon-style platform and paper screens references those origins.

Petr's arm lift
The bamboo is used differently here to create a reverse arm lift. It forces Petr to balance inelegantly on his toes, in order to alleviate the pressure on his shoulder joints. Foot fans will appreciate his lines. The other three poles are acting purely as decorative encumbrances at this moment
but they can be used to impose leg separation on the captive.

The Swimmer - On the bamboo ladder
As this bewildered soul has just discovered.
I've called him 'the swimmer' on account of the design of his trunks and his lithe muscularity. His confused look makes this picture tingle with possibilities. He's reacting to the unexpected warm-up slaps he's getting, but the bamboo ladder restraint frame is unusual enough to be suggestive of mysterious, exotic and demanding rituals. It is also a compact, more accessible alternative to conventional spread-eagling on a table or between uprights.

Vladimir (?) - Suspended on a cross
This is an impressive restraint image owing much to the model's tremendous physique, which is beautifully displayed giving an impression of true strength without excessive bulk. His shaved abdomen looks great. You can see his 'bits' have been 'enhanced' but his male-ness doesn't really need the help.

At first sight it looks like a crucifixion, but the captive is actually suspended by a combination of arm slings and  ankle restraints that won't allow him to put his feet on the ground. It's a double-edged sword of two uncomfortable positions that can be alternated but not escaped.

Ilya Pole Tied
This is potentially an even more fiendish restraint. A hoist levers Ilya's arms backwards but the upright pole limits his ability to change position to mitigate the pressure.  He is forced to adopt an involuntary submissive pose.


The effect of this tension on his body is most striking.
Firstly the muscularity of his arms is highlighted.
Second, his head is forced forward and down,
 which seems to accentuate the shape of his pecs and the washboard ripple of his abdominals.
Meanwhile, the keen cut of his underpants brings out some bulky, sexy, thigh muscularity.

Suspension Bondage 1
For a supple, young man this suspension position isn't problematic unless it's excessively prolonged. It's causes the buttocks to be beautifully displayed and that's further enhanced in this case by the subtle patterning of his underpants. I haven't been able to find out this model's name

Suspension Bondage 2
His long slender leg lines are brought out in this view 
and if you seek out more images from the set there are views of his back muscles


Roman is one of the best looking men in the Russian Captured Boys stable  and this intimate shot captures a sense of acceptance and reflection that enhances his masculine credentials.


Roman suspended
When drawn up by the chain into a suspended position,
 his stressed physique in this image is impressive.
It's a marvellous study of pure restraint 
unencumbered by the mechanics of the display.

'Guy Next Door' suspended and clamped

A similar suspension test is arranged for this model, supplemented by nipple clamps. If we were to go by the profuse sweating that is suggested by the gleaming highlights on his triceps, he would be long past the stage of worrying about the minor nuisance on his pecs. I suspect that the sheen is actually oil but I'm happy with that. The matching of a sober expression with a stretched out body produces another striking image that is about personality and inner emotions as much as outward physical appearance.

I previously featured this model, memorably clad in orange shorts,
 in a review of Torture Central a few years ago.
~
If you appreciate the beauty of the human body and of it's response to tension and pressure, you can understand how shibari came to be thought of as a sort of performance art. Judging from the images in this article, the men behind Russian Captured Boys seem to understand this. But their approach to bondage is much simpler, less sophisticated than shibari and that throws greater emphasis onto the intrinsic qualities of their models. The sparing use of clothing also contributes, avoiding the distraction of  explicit nudity which would otherwise overshadow everything else. It certainly doesn't prevent these images from being erotic. More on this next time.

Saturday, 11 January 2020

Priapus of Milet becomes All Time Most Popular Post in 2019

Priapus of Milet - Antechamber
A scene from 'Antechamber' by Priapus in which a husky, red head explores a post-holocaust labyrinth
 and is taken captive by robot-skeletons with a taste for tormenting human men.
Here they escort him to his next experience.
See the full series at Telemachus12

~

According to my Blogger 'hit stats', out of all the mitchmen articles published to date, 
those registering the most hits since publication were as shown below.


Table 1 mitchmen Articles With Most Hits Since Publication to end 2018

Posn
(last yr)
Title of Post
(& link)
Year of
Pub'n
2018
Hits
2019 Hits
1 (2)
2012
23787
30906
2 (1)
2010
24020
26717
3 (6)
2008
16830
23837
4 (5)
2009
13786
17666
5 (4)
2010
14385
16033
6 (18)
2017
5817
15238
7 (-)
2018
2519
14184
8 (6)
2009
11600
12849
9 (7)
2010
9500
11071
10 (10)
2009
6878
9814
11 (9)
2009
7284
8676
12 (8)
2012
7430
8410
13 (17)
2015
5946
8202
14 (10)
2012
6878
8059
15 (12)
2010
6442
7569
16 (-)
2009
4162
7460
17 (-)
2009
5618
7240
18 (14)
2009
6098
7122
19 (-)
2018
974
6929
20 (13)
2011
6145
6926


A couple of years ago I was gloomily pondering the rather static nature of this annual survey. How different things look now! Several recent articles featuring modern art styles have raced up the rankings and there are now 4 in the top 20 shaking up the order and dislodging old favourites such as (this year), Mahoney and Michael Mitchell (no relation!).

This year Priapus of Milet – 1 which arguably started the 'new wave' revolution way back(!) in 2012 finally dislodged A-Z of Fetish Artists – Mike Carcel from the No 1 position and has already established a commanding lead. With this artist regularly producing stunning new work over at Telemachus12 (see header picture) it's hard to see anyone catching him soon.

Mike Carcel on the other hand seems to have stopped publishing. Nowadays it's getting harder to find appropriate hosts for his rather demanding subject matter and his position in this survey is in danger of being taken over by A-Z of Fetish Artists – Cavelo next year. 
But both these artists are themselves under threat from behind.

Beyond these three leaders, the main action is the arrival of 'posts of the year', The Milking Factory and IFNB – A Fantasy World of Bodybuilder Morphs at 6 & 7 respectively both having risen dramatically this year (64 places for IFNB!). A second Milking Factories – 3 article also sneaked into 19th place in an equally astonishing rise from nowhere last year, others seem to share my view that the lead image in this article (by Cupcakes666) is magnificent. These posts have yet to prove their longevity but it seems likely that one of them will be challenging the top 3 next time despite the huge gap of over 8,000 hits to be bridged. It's an exciting change to the established order.

The two arrivals at 6 & 7 have split a gaggle of A-Z artists who have juggled positions this year (as usual) but continued to maintain significant hit rates, even after 10 years on the blog. Most of them have been pushed down a place or two by the upstarts but A-Z of Fetish Artists – Jotto (up 1) and A-Z of Fetish Artists – The Hun (no change) managed to resist the tide of change better than the others with Jotto recording a significantly increased hit rate, up by a third. Not to be dismissed just yet!

In these circumstances I am delighted (as you might expect) that my own 'A Christmas Criminal' story rose a creditable 4 places to 13. Admittedly, I do advertise it continuously in the blog sidebar but it is a piece I'm proud of. If 8,000 men have read it and enjoyed it, I am highly delighted.

Further down, two more 10 year old articles, A-Z of Fetish Artists – Julius and A-Z of Fetish Artists – Kalabro entered the top 20 for the first time. Julius' cause has probably been helped by my comprehensive revision of his original A-Z article and my occasional posts of 'doctored' frames from his stories, although I haven't done one for a while to give him more impetus. Kalabro has been hovering just outside the top 20 for a while and I have no doubt that the runaway success of the Milking Factory has given him added impetus. That first article was based on a group of pictures by him and it was they which inspired the whole series. So take a bow Kalabro!

For comparison, my 'Index of Artists' page reached 40807 hits at the end of 2019 (up from 26846) which would have earned top spot in this ranking if I counted it as a post. It shows the tremendous interest in artists who work in our field.


Years not presently represented in the survey

Average hit rates

The total cumulative hits method of assessing popularity is obviously biased towards older articles so it's interesting to compare average hits per year since publication - see table below. In this list, multi-part articles are represented by the highest scoring individual post only and I have left out 2019 posts which don't even have a full year yet and are covered by a separate table. (If I had included them they would have bagged many of the top 10 spots!) I've included 5 extra articles as well, to counterbalance the preponderance of 2017-18 articles

Table 2 Articles with the Highest Average Hits per year Since Publication
Article
Published
Hits per year
Position
(& last year)
'Total Hits' position
2018
7820
1 (-)
7
2017
5317
2 (2)
6
2012
4010
3 (1)
1
2018
3871
4 (-)
35
2010
2810
5 (3)
2
2008
2507
6 (4)
3
2017
2103
7 (7)
43
2015
2038
8 (5)
13
2017
1954
9 (6)
14
2009
1858
10 (9)
4





2018
1776
11 (-)
88
2010
1686
12 (8)
5
2009
1352
13 (10)
8
2018
1223
14 (-)
111
2014
1189
15 (12)
22

Last year the usual suspects still bagged most of the top spots, but this year the challenge from the newcomers, two of whom are already in the top echelons, is clear.

This method tends to benefit popular, newer articles in the short term and there are some other interesting beneficiaries this year just outside the top 10 - The Art of Sparkieshock and Tentacles in action. Historically these articles disappear just as quickly as they appeared if they do not keep up their high initial hit rates (remember Woodunart?). However there are signs of 2 'middle aged' posts consolidating a more permanent position in the top group as their average gradually becomes 'less dilutable' by the passing years, namely A Christmas Criminal at 8 and Bound & Gagged Magazine – 4 at 15. I suspect Chirenon's A New Life For Our Air Force Boys which has remained in 7th place despite the influx above it may also fall into this category.


I'm gradually revising and extending my oldest A-Z entries, the main beneficiaries this year were (with latest and previous positions) Brick 71 (83), RJ Blake 121 (-), Turquine 59 (59), Hasegawa 195 (-), plus late in the year I did Kaarlo who is presently not qualified for the table (887 hits). Also in December, the articles on Manflesh 27 (22) and Facchini 79 (89) were augmented by the transfer of galleries from the old Yahoo! Group but too late to affect this years figures.

The articles I post to this blog are very much based on my own interests and fancies but the results of this survey do help me plan future offerings. My readers preferences doesn't always match my own (where are Les, JoeT and Link?). Nevertheless it's gratifying to see such interest in the great artists who often have a fairly low visibility on the web.

Remember, this comparison is only made for entertainment, since I don't really know how accurate Google's stats are, I suspect they don't even count people who just browse through the blog roll.

Thanks to all of you for your continuing interest and support.

Wednesday, 8 January 2020

IFNB is the Most Popular 'All Comers' Post in 2019

 A recent post at IFNB showing a Mr Alpha contestant and his support assistant
 celebrating victory with a cup of juice.

According to my Blogger 'hit stats', out of all the mitchmen articles published to date,
those registering the most hits during 2019 were as shown below.

Table 1 – mitchmen Articles with Most Hits in 2019

Position
(& last year)
Article
Published
Hits in
2019
Hits in 2018
1 (6)
2018
11665
2516
2 (3)
2017
9421
4406
3 (2)
2012
7119
5722
4 (1)
2008
7007
6574
5 (-)
2018
5955
974
6 (-)
2018
4593
699
7 (5)
2009
3880
2836
8 (10)
2009
3298
2208
9 (7)
2009
2936
2507
10 (-)
2019
2820
-
11 (4)
2010
2697
2894
12 (-)
2018
2592
1110
13 (-)
2017
2536
1686
14 (-)
2018
2328
867
15 (11)
2015
2256
2169
16 (-)
2019
2238
50 (est)
17 (8)
2017
1954
2489
18 (-)
2018
1933
1045
19 (-)
2014
1778
799
20 (-)
2018
1741
861





21 (12)
2010
1686
1691
22 (18 )
2009
1622
1311
23 (13)
2010
1571
1550
24 (9)
2014
1567
2217
25 (-)
2017
1524
888
26 (16)
2014
1459
1342
27= (19 =)
2009
1392
1202
27= (-)
2018
1392
864
29 (-)
2019
1302
-
30
2018
1284
477

This table only shows hits registered during 2019 but for all articles, not just those first published in 2019. The titles in all the tables link to the original posts. Please tell me if you have difficulty with any links. Stats collected 31/12/19

These tables are usually dominated by the older articles on classic artists, but this year relative newcomers have overturned that. IFNB A Fantasy World of BodyBuilders, in it's first full year captured the top spot overtaking the original Milking Factory article which was already poised for success last year at No3. IFNB finished ahead by a substantial margin. There was an equally large gap down to Priapus of Milet-1 at No 3 (down 1 place). The phenomenal popularity of the IFNB and Milking Factory posts was very obvious to me during the year and the winning total was 75% higher than last year's winner A-Z of Fetish Artists – Cavelo (down to 4). Cavelo recorded just under 10% more hits but that wasn't anywhere near enough to hold back the new wave, or to prevent Priapus of Milet - 1 regaining the upper hand in their 3 year tussle. Priapus showed a 25% rise in hits which was the same as the overall increase in visits to the blog.

While The Milking Factory was pipped for top spot there was compensation of sorts from 3 other posts in the series which came in at 5, 10 and 14. With 2 further articles in the series appearing in the 2019 new articles list, this is definitely 'The Year of the Milking Factory'.

The other tsunami to sweep the chart this year was of course Homoeros who snatched 4 places (6, 12, 16, 20) including the surprise success of the Homoeros Gallery article which I talked about in the new articles list. His crucifixion images (The Art of Homoeros – 6) seem to attract most interest, more than double that of the first article in the series (The Art of Homoeros -1) which is a good indicator of the interest in his wider work.

Given the dominance of these multi-part series I'm also showing, this year, the next 10 articles in the table who might otherwise have made the higher positions. Most of these are ejectees from the 2018 top 20 but there are some interesting new entrants towards the bottom.
The notable (and gratifying) increase in visits to the blog recently (they've doubled in the last 3years) has helped to drive up the hit rates for new articles. The top 20 cut-off figure this year was 1741, compared with last years 1202, and this puts the historic performance of older articles under pressure. It will be interesting to see what the cumulative hit chart looks like this year. The visits picture this year went a bit crazy with extreme fluctuations from month to month which I can't explain. It doesn't seem to relate to the new posts I am making, because most visitors still go to the older stuff, as you will see if you look at the top 10 gadget which I added this year. The modest presence of two 2019 articles in the top 20 also reflects this preference.

One casualty of this turmoil was former perennial chart-topper Mike Carcel which dropped to No 11 with a small decline in new hits for the second consecutive year. I have lost track of where he is posting now (if anywhere) which may account for this dip. However Cavelo, Jotto, Julius and The Hun made a good fist of defending the 'old school' presence with decent increases in views. That was supplemented by the unexpected appearance of Teddy of Paris at No19. It's the first time he has registered in any of these charts and I'm absolutely delighted that his superb art is still garnering admirers. The continuing high levels of interest in traditional, fetish art sets the bar for new arrivals who have yet to show their own durability.

Two other distinctive representatives of the new wave made also welcome entries this year Chirenon 'A New Life For Our Airforce Boys' and The Art of Sparkieshock are representatives of fetish-inspired art that's very much of the 21st century

On a personal note it's nice to see A Christmas Criminal (ep 1-5) hanging on to a top 20 spot at 15. This article also effectively carried the flag for spanking this year. I don't regard myself as a spanking artist, but it features prominently in this particular story. There was also spanking support from Hunk Hunt – Mitch Colby 5 (which contains a spanking GIF). Mitch Colby (no relation!) is also the sole wrestling representative in the list and his is the only photography article. Of the rest, 3 articles are photo-manips, 11 are computer based art and 5 traditional art. It adds up to a resounding vote for imaginative, creative art.

That conclusion is reinforced by the 'Index of Artists' Page which recorded 13951 hits in 2019 (up 30%). This feature of the blog (introduced in 2015) is probably mainly responsible for the increase in visits overall, total blog visits this year were 696K, up 24% from 2018. The growth also coincides to some extent with a switch of focus at the blog from traditional, historic fetish art to more modern exponents as the A-Z series came to a close. Either way I'm glad visitors are finding the index useful and hope it will lead many more newcomers to a fantastic heritage of gay art they never saw before.


Total mitchmen blog visits for all years are now 3.57 million (2.88)

Next time I will reveal the all time table of cumulative hits
did Mike Carcel keep his spot at the top?


Thanks to all of you for your continuing interest and support.

Sunday, 5 January 2020

The Twelfth Day of Christmas (Bareass Blogs Special No 40)


Bareass Bottoms-Up Band Beating the Retreat

"We've made sure those 12 bloody drummers 
won't be coming down our street on a Sunday morning next year!"

(and by a happy chance 12th night falls on a Sunday this year! 😉)

Originally published in greyscale as part of my
"This Christmas will be .....different" series
(which is available in full at mitchmen club at Adonis Male) 


Friday, 3 January 2020

Milking Factory 4 is mitchmen Most Popular New Post of 2019

 At this time of year it is my custom to review the last year's posts to see which attracted the most visitors. This year I have changed my approach by including some posts from the previous year which were published too late to get fair recognition last time and ranking them all based on a time-averaged hit rate. The full rationale for this change is explained here.

Detail of Sarander's 'Alien Semen Farm' (from Milking Factories-4)

According to my Blogger 'view count' stats, the 20 posts listed below
 are the most-visited mitchmen articles out of the 127 published in 2019
 This total compares with 119 in 2018. The titles have links to the individual posts.


2019 Most Popular Post
Table based on average hit rate (not total hits)
2019 Rank
(total hits rank)
Title
Hit Rate
pa
Publication
Date
1 (1)
2949
Jan
2 (2)
2186
Dec '18
3 (7)
1811
May
4 (5)
1672
Mar
5 (11)
1535
May
6 (13)
1361
Jun
7 (4)
1316
Jan
8 (18)
1185
July
9 (6)
1136
Dec '18
10 (16)
1036 est
Jun
11 (20)
883
May
12 (10)
865
Nov '18
13 (14)
833
May
14 (8)
830
Sep '18
15 (9)
745
Aug '18
16 (19)
718
Apr
17 (22)
688
Apr
18 (12)
668
Dec '18
19 (23)
652
Apr
20 (15)
640
Jan
21 (17)
624
Feb
22 (21)
617
Mar
Stats collected on 31st December 2019

This new style ranking contains a large number (6) of 2018 posts but 4 of them (including the highest 3) were published in December or November 2018 so their inclusion is not very hard to justify. I excluded Wrestling Arsenal (also from December 2018) because it actually made the 2018 list - an exceptional occurrence. The 2 posts from earlier in 2018 are slightly more controversial, but their hit counts have been averaged over a much longer period and so demonstrate a significant sustained interest which what this exercise aims to identify. However I have also included 2 extra 2019 posts in the list to allow readers to cancel out these 'anomalies' if they wish

The rankings in brackets are based on the old-style 'total hits' method which obviously favours older articles but doesn't change the top spots as much as you might expect.

The list is dominated by the three 'Milking Factory' posts at 1, 3 and 7 which have emulated the spectacular success of their predecessors, helped a little, I suspect, by the introduction of the 'Popular Posts' sidebar at the blog which has been dominated by this series recently and channels more readers to view them. The winner this year (reproduced above) was way ahead of the second-placed article but at 2949 did not quite manage to catch the previous years scores of Wrestling Arsenal (an exceptional 9195) and IFNB (3096). Wrestling Arsenal would have also finished 5th in this years list had I included it, but enough is enough!

The success of the Milking articles was not a surprise but the appearance of Homoeros Gallery at No2 was. This article is no more than a guide to that artist's websites but there was a surge in visits in the closing weeks of the year which lifted it into this lofty position. 
It's a reflection of the level of interest in the artist.

Seeing 'Kasee's Humiliation' at No 4 did please me. This is (almost)the 'wrestling' article I have always wanted to write, ever since I saw a handsome novice being thoroughly humiliated by an old hand on late night TV many years ago. (I say 'almost' because the 'victim' in the match I remember more resembled Kasee's tormentor, Cason, and his nemesis was much bigger and older). Anyway, Kasee and his handsome tormentor followed up the previous success of wrestling articles on Wrestling Arsenal (2018) and Mitch Colby (2017). The 'Humiliation of Chace La Chance' (great body, terrible name!),  published in May, narrowly missed inclusion but has a chance(!) of making next years list.

There are 8 'Art of ...' articles in the list this year headed up by the excellent Ephorox, a long overdue arrival at this blog. Ivan Bubentkov was a notable and worthy beneficiary of the change in my ranking inclusion criteria, I recently discovered more of his work I hope to share here in 2020. The retrospective feel of his art was complemented by 2 golden oldies – Colt and Hasegawa. These two are genuinely great artists and I'm glad my followers appreciate them too. Modern artists TooBoShoo and Chuckie79 missed the hit count criteria this year but look certain to feature in next years list. Only 3 of the top 20 articles were based purely on photographs (Kasee, Get Carter! and Taken off the Street-1). It reminds me that although I like to have a varied magazine format at this blog, most visitors come for the Art.

The Hasegawa article is another minor anomaly in this years list. This was a comprehensive rewrite of my 2009 A-Z article on him but, unusually for 'upgrades', I published it completely anew this year. That's why I've included it in the 2019 list (plus the fact that I admire him so much!). I had to adjust the hit count to isolate this years figure. Unfortunately, (and astonishingly) the original article had never made it's way into my 'top articles' spreadsheet so I had no record of the opening count for 2019, I've had to rely on memory, hence the est(imate) tag in the table, but I am certain he's in the right position.

Hasegawa was part of an informal 'Asian Festival' which I instigated this year, prompted by the slightly embarrassing realisation that Chace La Chance's opponent, Jessie Lee, was probably the first model of Asian heritage to ever get decent exposure here (although I have featured Asian artists here many times, so don't shout at me!). Most of these articles were in the second half of the year and missed this year's cut. I plan to run this feature into the New Year with posts on Fundoshi and the Speedo erotica that Asian men seem to have made their own.

I've put more of myself into the blog in recent years so I'm gratified to see one of my own pictures (and it's one of my personal favourites) in the top 20 again this year - Sports Star Kidnap at No 16. I was surprised however that the colourised 'nude' version didn't attract so many viewings. Perhaps many of you share my prediliction for modest, traditional underwear wearers in fetish encounters! Even more unexpectedly, 2 of my 'War Comic cuts' squeezed in at 15 and 18 (also helped by the rule change this year). These articles don't seem to generate much excitement when they are first published but the interesting fetish content (captives staked out or tied to railway lines) seems to have been recognised more gradually over the course of the year.

The appearance of last years MPP, 'Top Post' analyses at 7 and 20 is also flattering in a way and suggests new visitors are finding them interesting and helpful but I'd have preferred these places to have been occupied by meatier articles.

These small, personal successes have been some compensation for the upheaval of Yahoo zapping my permanent gallery which had been on display at the mitchmen group since 2007. As I write the fate of the mailing list seems to be hanging in the balance too, but we all move on and the replacement 'Club' at Adonis Male is shaping up to be an even better showcase.

Remember, this comparison is only made for entertainment, since I don't really know how accurate Google's stats are, I suspect they don't even count people who just browse through the blog roll.

Thank you to all my readers for your interest in my blog,
I will publish the updated all-time list of favourites shortly.


Happy New Year!

Most Popular Posts Listing - A Change In Method

Naked Thinker

At this time of year it is my custom to review the posts for the year just ended to see which attracted the most visitors. This year I have changed my approach to try and produce a more representative selection. For this year's list I have included some posts from the previous year (2018) which were published too late in that year to impact on the list. I have evened out the distortions caused by different publication dates by ranking them all based on a time- averaged hit rate*. The full result is shown and discussed in Most Popular Posts of 2019, this article explains the new methodology

Rationale for change of method

I have agonised in recent years about the arbitrary nature of this annual survey. As it is simply based on accumulated hit counts, the timing of publication significantly affects the opportunity to score and hence the position in the table. Thoroughly deserving posts often don't get chosen at all. Typically posts after mid year don't have enough time to register anywhere in the top 20. Wrestling Arsenal (December 2018) was a startling and unique exception last time, but notable recent anomalies were 'BuiltByTallSteve' and Chirenon's 'A New Life For Our Airforce Boys' both published in late 2017. Neither of these got a mention in their year of publication despite turning in a top 10 performance in their first 12 months.

This year (2019) nothing after July made the cut based on total hits. At the other end of the scale several posts from December 2018 registered counts during 2019  that would have got them into the top 20 in any year since records began (as they say) had their publication date been more favourable.

To address these issues I have cast my net a little wider this year, looking right back to mid 2018 to see if any of those posts ought to be recognised. Based on my usual criteria (i.e. considering 2019 posts only) the cut-off point for inclusion in the 2019 top 20 would have been 475 total hits or if I based the selection on an average hit rate* that irons out duration differences, the cut would have been 617 hits per year (pa).

I compiled a short list of posts from 2019 and the second half of 2018 which met both these criteria but excluding those that had previously made it into the 2018 chart. This gave me a list of 23 posts in total which left me some scope for 'tweaking' anomalies in the final top 20. 

The cut-off figures of the top 20 in this selection were lifted by about 10%  by this process, but for the top 23 they were exactly the same as they would have been under the old method. This is because the 2018 additions in the new list were offset by the loss of 2019 posts which met the total count criteria but had taken much longer to reach it.
Under this new method, late posts from 2019 still get excluded, but they have a second chance of inclusion next year when they have proven more durable appeal.

The table below shows all the affected articles listed in order of total hits since publication
2018 articles brought in under the new method are shown in red italics.
2019 articles excluded under the new method are shown in green
Column 2 shows how the table would have looked under the old system.
I discuss the results after the table.

Old Style Table Based on total hits since publication
New
Rank
Old Rank
Title
Hits
Publication
1
1
2820
Jan
2

2288
Dec '18
3

1697
Dec '18
4
2
1302
Jan
5
3
1269
Mar
6

1176
Dec '18
7
4
1166
May
8

1051
Sep '18
9

1031
Aug '18
10

1002
Nov '18
11
5
938
May
12

701
Dec '18
13
6
690
Jun
14
7
639
May
15
8
605
Jan
16
9
602 est
Jun
17
10
544
Feb
18
11
539
July
19
12
537
Apr

13
528
Jan
20
14
520
May

15
518
Jan

16
505
Jan
21
17
504
Mar

18
489
Jan
22
19
486
Apr
23
20
475
Apr
Stats collected on 31st December 2019

This table vividly demonstrates the effect of publication timing once again, with nothing after July 2019 making the cut and the first seven posts published in 2019 all getting in. Unsurprisingly the older, newly-included 2018 posts do well in this basic hit count table, but the top 2 posts are actually the same under the new system too with the same winner romping away with the title
 (see final MPP ranking article for 2019).

The three 2019 articles excluded from the table by the new criteria are shown in green above. All these articles had a full 12 months to make their score so replacing them with three far better performers from December 2018 is not an earth-shattering injustice. I scored a bit of an own goal by excluding No 16, but the 'War Comic' article that's linked to it gets into the new ranking at No 9 so I'm happy with that.

The winning total of 2820 comfortably exceeds last years record by IFNB of 2519 by about 12%, but this primarily reflects a longer scoring period (12 months for Milking Factories vs 9 for IFNB). Also, total visits to the site increased by 24%. this year so this performance probably doesn't count as a meaningful 'record'.

The full final results produced by the new system come out slightly different and are discussed in Most Popular Posts of 2019

*The Average (Annualised) hit rate was calculated as follows
(Total Hits) divided by (Days since Publication) multiplied by 365 (days in a year)
This does not produce a 'real' number, the formula reduces the counts of articles that have been around more than a year and inflates those published less than 12 months ago but they end up on a level playing field for comparison purposes.


Remember, these comparisons are only made for entertainment only, since I don't really know how accurate Google's stats are and I suspect they don't even count people who just browse through the blog roll.

Thank you to all my readers for your interest in my blog,
I will publish the updated all-time list of favourites shortly.

 

Happy New Year!